Alice Miles
Over 900 restaurants nationwide. Find your nearest now
They can't give it away. So bad is the economic situation that the Government will have to admit next week that it cannot stimulate the economy by fast-tracking great capital projects.
So complex are the systems now, so unwieldy the planning process and so untrusted the Government, that the proposals and partners do not exist to build our way out of the downturn. Many billions of pounds are already stuck in the system, unspent. The £43 billion Building Schools for the Future programme, for instance, that aims to rebuild 3,500 schools in 15 years, managed in its first three years to rebuild... 13.
So ministers have turned to tax cuts, aimed at the poorer, to keep Britain spending. At a time when we are in deep trouble because of stupid levels of personal and public debt - the true level of the latter amounting to £76,000 for each household by John Major's reckoning - the Government plans to increase debt farther and to encourage people who can least afford it to spend more. It's a reckless and immoral approach and the failure of the Conservative Party to make political capital out of it has been astonishing.
Yesterday David Cameron began to fight back. He ran through the phrases belted out by Gordon Brown over the past decade, such as, “you cannot spend your way out of recession”, or “to make unfunded promises, to play fast and loose with stability (indeed to play politics with stability) is... something I will never do and the British people will not accept”.
In a good, clear speech the Tory leader set out the attack line that will determine the outcome of the next election: that in this economic climate you have to be realistic about limiting public spending if taxpayers are not to be hit with soaring bills.
It will strike a chord. I cannot be the only person bridling at the thought of funding a Christmas bonanza for those already receiving large amounts of tax credits (many of those claims already a fraud on the taxpayer, as everyone outside the Whitehall bubble knows).
All around the country people are tightening their belts, scrapping plans for holidays, cutting back on excess spending, imposing strict budgetary limits on Christmas. All around the country people are preparing for unemployment and perhaps the loss of their homes. If they do keep their jobs, these same people will be the ones eventually asked to pay for the big bung that the Government appears to be planning next week: £15 billion or £30 billion of handouts specifically to encourage those who could not otherwise afford it, to spend money - redistribution from you and me to them and FlatscreenTelliesRUs. That's another thousand or two to add to the household tax bill and it probably won't even work.
There is no mystery about Mr Brown's new-found confidence, the spring in his step: the Prime Minister has found his feet. He always was far more Labour than new Labour, far keener on redistribution, less persuaded of the need for reforms that now seem irrelevant in the light of the larger crisis.
Since he took office, the Blairite public service agenda has withered. Those trying to reform schools and hospitals speak of a lack of drive and enthusiasm for change from No10, and this was before the credit crisis really hit. Academies are being pulled back into the State's embrace, forced to work more closely with local authorities in areas ranging from extended schools to attendance records and “quality asssurance”. Hospital closures have been put on hold. Even the bankrupt post offices were miraculously saved last week. Well, why not? All the banks have been.
The only area where Blairite reforms are driving energetically ahead is in welfare, where from next Monday, lone parents will have to be available for work for 16 hours a week once their youngest child is 12, instead of 16. In two years' time, it will be when the youngest is 7.
Campaigners are protesting that this is unfair. “Some mothers think that they should be able to see their children through the transition to secondary school,” one protested to me. Tough. Plenty of working parents already lack that luxury; lone parents should be at work, or actively seeking it. The assumption of eternal entitlement reveals a lot about people who have become used to living off the state. National reserves of sympathy and understanding for them will dry up farther as the next year wears on.
Mr Brown didn't have much of a story to tell about his premiership, but the global financial crisis has given the Prime Minister his own play to star in: Gordon, Saviour of the Universe. Blairites fear that Mr Brown is playing a short-term political game, and nothing else; charging through each day, no pause, no discussion, no strategy.
They worry that he has become carried away by his image of himself as a world leader. The much vaunted “broad and concerted international macroeconomic policy response in fiscal policy” agreed at the G20, ie, Mr Brown's permission to dish out tax cuts, was in fact 21 words in a statement of 3,600 - and those 21 words included the warnings “as appropriate” and if “conducive to fiscal sustainability”.
Thanks to the recent Tory slump, the bluff and the bravado seems to be working. The pollster MORI now has the Conservatives down to a three-point lead. Push really, really hard and you can even get some Labour insiders to consider an election next year, if the poll numbers are there, if party support for Cameron collapses over the winter, etc.
It's all quite similar to the Prime Minister's brief period of popularity last summer. Then, as now, national threats (foot-and-mouth, terrorist attacks, flooding) enabled the Prime Minister to define himself. And we all remember what happened after that.
In these uncertain times, it isn't only the economy that is terribly vulnerable to boom and bust.

Alice Miles has been with The Times since 1999. She began as a Parliamentary Sketch writer before becoming a columnist, writing mainly on politics and national issues such as education and health. She won Columnist of the Year in 2007.
The moment your toes touch the sand and your gaze meets water, you know you’re in the Bahamas.
Risk, resilience and embracing new technology
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2005 / 55
£59,500
Great car insurance deals online
Circa £60,000
The Army Benevolent Fund
London
C£100K+
Chronophage
Isle of Man
12-15 days a year, c £12K
Springboard
London
£Competitive
American Airlines
Heathrow, London
Great Investment, River Views
One and Two Bed Apartments
Wandsworth Town
Times Online Property Search will help you Find It
like nothing on Earth!
.
Must end 28 Feb 2009!
Save up to 25%
Amazing Far East Offers
Visit Malaysia from £755pp
Great travel insurance deals online
.
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths | Subscriptions
News International associated websites: Globrix Property Search | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I am 57, divorced with two grown-up children and, earning £10,000 per year, could fairly be said to be low-paid. Because I only work 23.5 hours weekly I don't qualify for tax credits. I am almost certain there must be thousands like me who don't meet Gordon Brown's "hard-pressed" family criteria
Philip Roger Burt, Wick, Caithness
William Jones above quotes the IMF. It was the IMF who along with the OECD & EU Commission stated that the UK is the worst placed of any major economy to face the downturn. Brown when faced with this statement just said 'they are wrong.'
So they are right when it suits him, wrong when it doesn't!!
Kim, Bristol, uk
Alice, you are spot on, thank you for saying what has needed to be said for a long time! I never benefited during the Boom??
I''ve now just been rejected by the police because I may be racist?? Still no job.
I'm going to go all guns for emigration to Australia, there's nothing here for me now
Graham, St. Albans, uk
shouldn't we all remember who stoked up the economy, taxed and spent, allowed credit and mortgages to get way out of hand,...self certification....a charter for exageration to obtain a mortgage !.....and then has the bare faced cheek to enter stage left as the saviour...... do me a favour !
Andrew Simpson, Taunton,
Excellent article.....well said
Phil, Preston,
Gwen, ditch the people carrier and get your children second hand bikes or let them travel by bus and walk if there's a service in Cardington. I did it when I was a child (10 mile round trip to school). Much healthier. That's what legs are for ...
Anya, Sedgeford,
Thank you to Alice Miles for doing what Cameron and Osborne have signally failed to do, which is to hit the open goal that is Labour's current policy and message. Bribing us with our own money is just a cheap stunt designed purely to court short-term popularity, and Brown is a preening fraud.
Stuart Calder, London,
Only a matter of time before those of us who have paid our National Insurance "premiums" discover that there are no funds to pay out in our time of need because all the cash has been spent supporting non-contributors. Don't make it worse by paying out more to those who have not paid in.
Bob, Reading,
Unfortunately I do remember the 1970s when Britain was forced to go to the IMF under a Labour Government.
Like courage, prudence has turned out to be something that Brown only talks about rather than practices. When he talks about saving the world, he means saving his job.
John Goode, Welwyn Garden City, UK
Any more articles like this and I will start buying the Times! Well written and bang on target...
Dean, Manea, Cambs, England
Fact is,giving money to the poor to buy more luxuries, will make our trade balance even worse. And this is from a government that has not built a single power station in 11 years!
David Vinter,, Louth, Lincs,, UK.
Brown only has his eye on one thing, the next general election. After that he'll either be out of power and won't care, or in power for another five years and won't care.
David Leslie, Perth, Scotland
Gwen could sell her people carrier to help settle her credit card debts and pay off a bit of the mortgage. I bet there is a bus stop right outside her house. Send the kids to school in a socially responsible way not by the most expensive means possible. A vehicle unused and wasting away. Tut tut!!
Disgusted, Tunbridge Wells, Middle England
The IMF also reported back in 2005 that UK was grossly in debt. They were ignored. Now they say extra spending is necessary. Yes BUT THEY DID NOT SAY GROSS overborrowing was the wasy forward and that is Brown's policy. The Institute of Directors are just hoping for a kick back!
M. Cawdery, Portadown, Co. UK, EU Courtesy Brown
Maybe if papers like The Time published more articles like these and less of the self-congratulatory nonsense emanating from No. 10, the people would know the truth about Brown. He created this mess and thinks he is uniquely placed to clean it up. Let's have a real poll - it's called an election.
Nobby Clark, Perth, the Scottish one,
My son is 21 and on a university degree in architecture. His debt piles up mitigated to some extent by paid professional practice but even that has now ground to a halt. Firm in the blues not enough work to sustain the student extras. What is it going to be like when he graduates? I dread to think.
Flabergasted, Tunbridge Wells, Middle England
"Gwen Charlotte says it all. This sort of behaviour is selfish, antisocial and unsustainable. Get these people off the roads." Not sure I get this - what's so unreasonable about someone taking their kids to school when it's clearly too far to walk?? Pete - I think you're the one being anti-social.
Rob, Totnes, UK
Brown is a baby-boomer so it's "all about me".
He's sentencing the young to huge university debt; fewer proper graduate jobs; a bloated yet inefficient state; still high house prices but fewer mortgages and now burgeoning borrowing which someone will have to repay.
I would hate to be 21 ...
Jan, Sussex, UK
Gwen Charlotte says it all. This sort of behaviour is selfish, antisocial and unsustainable. Get these people off the roads.
Pete, Cheshire.
Peter Caulkett, Macclesfield, UK
I am sure we are all cut-up about Gwen's road tax for her people carrier - in my opinion this is a perfect use of the tax
Duncan, London, UK
stunning article - and absolutely spot-on.
pete, ludlow, england
Perhaps if Santa did something about the absurd stealth Road Tax regime, it would benefit those of us who actually pay taxes...
My People Carrier faces a 416 pound bill for road tax and is only used twice a day to run the kids to and from school - a 15 mile journey. Tax costs more than fuel!
Gwen Charlotte, Cardington, Bedforshire
Brown is dancing with the pixies - we've already had the fiscal stimulus- massive budget deficits over the last few years, its just putting off the day of reckoning -piling debt onto debt.
Chris, London,
IMF head supports a fiscal stimulus for world economies at this crucial time. The IOD and all world political leaders support Gordon Brown's kick start plan for the UK economy. Sadly, the Tories think small, and will cut investment in schools, hospitals, Sure Start and services vital to our people
William Jones, Bangor, UK
IMF head says economies like the UK need a big kick-start and Gordon Brown's plan will deliver this. The Instiute of Directors supports Labour's approach as do all world political leaders. Out on their own, Cameron, Osborne & Co. small ideas will cut investment in schools, hospitals and child care
William Jones, Bangor, UK